Best Mattress Protector

A mattress will only serve the purpose of enabling sound sleep if it is kept in good shape – but that shouldn’t be so difficult, right? From personal experience, I would advise you to think again: there are multiple threats that can harm and greatly reduce the usability of your mattress (and by extension, the quality of your sleep).

Fluids, moisture, allergens such as dust mites, mold, fungi, and bed bugs; these are what I like to refer to as the ‘usual suspects’. The good news is that all of the aforementioned nuisances can be dealt with through a single, simple product: the mattress protector.

By coming between the outside environment and the mattress, it keeps out all the nasties so that your mattress remains almost good as new for as long as possible. The trick is to choose the best mattress protector to match your bed, and that’s what I’ll help you do with this in-depth guide.

Table of Contents

Best Mattress Protector Comparisons

Brand

Material (surface / membrane)

Waterproof

Allergen Proof

Bedbug Proof

Warranty

Extra Features

Our Ratings

Tencel surface,
polyurethane membrane

Yes

Yes

No

10 years

Nature derived top surface, inherently anti-bacterial

Cotton terry surface, plastic membrane

Yes

Yes

No


15 years 

Does not use PVC or phthalates, made in USA

Viny

Yes

Yes

No

10 years

Rated for 300 machine cycles; free from phthalates and BPA

Polyester surface, Polyurethane membrane

Yes

Yes

No


10 years


Vinyl free

OmniGuard Advance surface, polyurethane membrane

Yes

Yes

Yes

10 years

Anti-microbial AgCl lining, washable on hot setting, OEKO Tex® certified

Polyester 98% / Lycra surface, Outlast(R) PCM, plastic membrane

Yes

Yes

No

60 days

Outlast(R) Gold standard phase change mechanism, made in USA

Why Do You Need A Mattress Protector?

If the mere mention of the usual suspects doesn’t alarm you enough, here is a detailed breakdown of why they are bad news, and why a mattress cover will help you against them:

  • Fluids and moisture
  • Allergens
  • Bed bugs
  • Voided warranty

As if dust mites aren’t trouble enough, your bed may also come to harm from a far more persistent enemy: bed bugs are tiny insects that thrive on your blood. They can make their way inside your home concealed in everyday items such as garments, luggage and furniture.
Once inside your mattress, they will lay hundreds of eggs that will eventually lead to an infestation. They become active at night and feed via your skin for up to 10 minutes, leaving bites that are initially painless but later become irritated welts.

If you do not counter these insects at the first sign, the infestation may become irreversible, to the point that your mattress may have to be disposed of (or permanently sealed to keep the bugs inside for good).

A six-sided, encasement style protector that envelops (and seals off) your mattress from all sides will effectively keep bed bugs out.

What To Consider When Buying A Protector?

Waterproofing

Mattress covers are available in multiple degrees of water resistance – some are fully waterproof, others are partly so, while some aren’t waterproof at all. Waterproofing is directly related to micron size i.e. the size of the microscopic holes in the protector’s membrane.

A tighter micron size results in stronger waterproofing, but it also means less breathability (i.e. you may sleep hot at night). Therefore, you need to carefully consider the degree of waterproofing you require, so that you don’t have to deal with a higher temperature rise than is necessary.

Allergen Proofing

Allergen proofing is, again, tied with micron size – the smaller the size of the hole, the harder it will be for tiny insects i.e. dust mites and bed bugs, to burrow in. If you’re dealing with an acute dust mite issue, try to look for a product that clearly specifies a micron size of 1 or less.

While a bed bug infestation does not classify as an allergenic concern, it is worth discussing here because it is just as much a nuisance. Only a thoroughly zippered, six-sided protector will provide adequate safety against bed bugs – but since it will enclose the mattress from all sides, it will also lead to a temperature rise.

Only go for a six sided protector if you’re sure that you’re dealing with bed bugs in your house, otherwise, you’ll do just fine with a decent four sided (fitted sheet style) protector.

Materials

There are several types of mattress protectors, based on materials; and the type of material has a direct impact on protection, thermal regulation, and overall comfort provided by the mattress cover.

  • Cotton
  • Plastics
  • Organic Derivatives

Advanced high-end products may use derivatives of natural materials such as eucalyptus, bamboo, latex and wool, for creating mattress covers that provide functionality coupled with a high degree of luxury.

They are expensive of course, but they offer unparalleled cooling and moisture wicking compared to mainstream products. Oftentimes, they also come with the added benefits of inborn anti-bacterial protection.

Furthermore, such protectors are suitable for individuals who are uncomfortable being in contact with artificial plastics that may have long term health hazards.

Heat Dissipation

Heat dissipation is related to the type of material used for the top surface, the permeability of the underlying protective membrane, as well as the environment you plan to use the cover in.

These factors have already been discussed in detail in the previous subsections, so be sure to keep them in mind when making your choice, especially if you’re picking a cover for a memory foam mattress (they are inherently heat retentive).

Comfort

Comfort is a highly subjective experience, but in this context, I’ll discuss it in terms of the surface feel of the protector. For most people, the best mattress cover with regards to comfort would be one that serves its protective functions without having any impact on the overall feel of your bed.

This is, of course, impossible to achieve entirely, but there are certain ultra-slim protectors that can actually come quite close – these, however, aren’t as reusable as thicker products, and are prone to breaking down if laundered improperly.


Reusability

This is an important determinant if you’re using the protector for chronic bedwetting problems. You’ll need a protector that can be cleaned up and be ready to use again as quickly as possible. A vinyl cover will suit you best, since this tough material keeps the fluid on its surface so it can be simply wiped away with a wet cloth.

Other materials that are more absorbent will need to be laundered, and that is where the true test of durability comes in. A cheap product with a weak membrane will fail after a few washes, while a superior product may last for several dozen washes.

Unfortunately, there is no sure shot way of predicting the reusability of a product. Your best bet is to scour through consumer reviews which will portray a more or less accurate picture of how long the protector will last.

Warranty

While not always true, the period of warranty coverage can give you an indication of how reliable a product is. The industry average is 10 years, but higher end products often come with a 15 year warranty.

Generally, a product with favorable user feedback and a decade long or higher warranty claim should last you through multiple washings. Conversely, a period shorter than this implies poor quality since the manufacturer is unwilling to stand behind their product for long.


Third Party Certifications

Several top tier manufacturers have gotten their products certified by reputed third party organizations to ease the consumer concerns pertaining to the environment- and health-friendliness of the materials used in their protectors.

Examples include the GREENGUARD Certification and the STANDARD 100 OEKO-Tex®, both of which certify that the product does not contain harmful chemicals that could negatively affect the quality of air in your home.

These safety standards are particularly important for people who plan to use mattress protectors in their children’s rooms.

Give It A Test First

If you plan on using a protector for a super expensive mattress that you absolutely don’t want stained, it is always better to test your purchased mattress cover on a secondary, less critical surface.

Simply spill some water in the protector’s middle and observe it every half hour. You will be able to deduce the effectiveness of the product’s waterproof membrane quite easily in this manner, and in case there’s any trouble, you can claim its warranty without learning about the defect after your main bed is ruined!

Top Rated Mattress Protector Reviews

Protect-A-Bed Luxury Waterproof Mattress Protector

Key Points

    • Material: Tencel surface,
      polyurethane membrane
    • Waterproof: Yes
    • Allergen Proof: Yes
    • Bed Bug Proof: No
    • Extra Features: Nature derived top surface, inherently anti-bacterial
    • Warranty: 10 years

The protector’s top surface has been made from eucalyptus leaves – a material known as Tencel, which makes it softer, cooler and more absorbent than cotton (and most definitely plastic) while also lending it hypoallergenic and anti-bacterial capabilities.

For keeping out allergens and fluids, the product uses the ‘Miracle Membrane’ – a waterproof layer underneath the surface that keeps out moisture and mites while still allowing for adequate air flow. Coupled with the Tencel on top, this ensures solid protection alongside ample thermal regulation.

There have been only a few complaints regarding the long term reliability of the cover, and in any case, the 10 year warranty should have you covered in case of a defect. One thing that should be noted is that the use of organic material makes the product a bit pricey.

Pros

    • Natural surface layer.
    • Superb cooling, comfort and moisture wicking.
    • Anti-bacterial and hypoallergenic.
    • 10 year warranty.

Cons

    • Expensive.
    • Limited complaints regarding defects.

Recommended For

This mattress cover is geared towards those who are temperature conscious during sleep, so that they require reasonable protection with minimal rise in temperature.

Luna Premium Mattress Protector

Key Points

    • Material: Cotton terry surface, plastic membrane
    • Waterproof: Yes
    • Allergen Proof: Yes
    • Bed Bug Proof: No
    • Extra Features: Does not use PVC or phthalates, made in USA
    • Warranty: 15 years

Thanks to a cotton terry surface the protector doesn’t feel wrinkly like cheap plastic products, which enhances its overall low profile. Furthermore, the plastic membrane doesn’t heat up as much as the competition because of Luna’s Waterproof Airflow Technology which is able to keep out allergens and fluids while remaining breathable.

The plastic membrane is devoid of harmful substances such as phthalates and PVC. While the cover has received largely favorable feedback for its unobtrusive nature and reliability, the slim profile also necessitates caution while laundering since it can easily get damaged by hot water.

Impressively, the protector comes with a 15 year warranty, which is higher than the market average.

Pros

    • Dependable, unnoticeable performance.
    • Surface cotton terry layer enhances comfort.
    • Plastic membrane is free of dangerous chemicals.
    • 15 year warranty.

Cons

    • Slim profile means it is prone to damage from hot water during laundering.

Recommended For

Thanks to a remarkably thin form factor, the Luna mattress protector is suited to people who wish to keep the feel of their bed unaltered even as they use a cover for warding off damage.

Priva Hypoallergenic Waterproof Vinyl Mattress Protector

Key Points

    • Material: Vinyl
    • Waterproof: Yes
    • Allergen Proof: Yes
    • Bed Bug Proof: No
    • Extra Features: Rated for 300 machine cycles; free from phthalates and BPA
    • Warranty: 10 years

It is made from vinyl, yet its surface is softer and more unnoticeable than routine plastic protectors – this I’ve deduced from consumer feedback. Naturally, since it is plastic, you can expect it to get a little hotter than organic materials.

If you’re concerned about the hazards of exposing yourself to vinyl, you should know that this cover’s vinyl is free from both BPA and phthalates, that major miscreants associated with this plastic.

The most useful aspect of this product is its 300 wash cycle rating – this is a far larger rating than the majority of products in its price range, and this is exactly why I recommend it for people who can’t be bothered with careful, low-heat laundering to extend their cover’s lifetime.

The manufacturer advertises this cover as being a ‘bed bug barrier’ when it is quite clearly not – it is a fitted sheet style product that does not cover up the back of the mattress from where beg bugs can easily make their way in.

A 10 year warranty accompanies this protector.

Pros

    • Cheap.
    • Highly reusable and easy to clean.
    • Vinyl is durable, free from harmful substances, and offers superb waterproofing.
    • Not as plastic feeling as one would expect.
    • 10 year warranty.

Cons

    • Tends to get a little hot.
    • Not a bed bug barrier as touted.

Recommended For

This low cost protector is intended for use with cases of extreme bedwetting where frequent cleaning is needed.

LINENSPA Premium Mattress Protector

Key Points

    • Material: Polyester surface, Polyurethane membrane
    • Waterproof: Yes
    • Allergen Proof: Yes
    • Bed Bug Proof: No
    • Extra Features: Vinyl free
    • Warranty: 10 years

Its thin, flexible polyester top lets it sit undetectable on your mattress, so you can enjoy the feel of your bed without any major change. The waterproof membrane is made out of polyurethane – a relatively safe form of plastic that keeps the harmful stuff out without exposing you to noxious chemicals.

The product has received praise for its excellent fitting, dependability, and understated performance, a formidable achievement given its cheap price tag. That said, the Linenspa protector isn’t completely without flaw – there have been a few complaints pertaining to QA, but these are part and parcel with a product this inexpensive.

The manufacturer has included a 10 year warranty with this cover.

Pros

    • Extremely cheap.
    • Reasonably reliable protection against major threats.
    • Doesn’t have a big effect on overall mattress feel.
    • Free from harmful vinyl.
    • 10 year warranty.

Cons

    • Limited concerns about durability.

Recommended For

If you’ve depleted your cash reserves after spending big on an expensive mattress, and now you’re looking for a low cost, chemically safe solution to secure it against common threats, you may want to consider the Linenspa Premium Mattress Protector.

PureCare Total Encasement Mattress Protector

Key Points

    • Material: OmniGuard Advance surface, polyurethane membrane
    • Waterproof: Yes
    • Allergen Proof: Yes
    • Bed Bug Proof: Yes
    • Extra Features: Anti-microbial AgCl lining, washable on hot setting, OEKO Tex® certified
    • Warranty: 10 years

The surface of the cover is made from OmniGuard Advance fabric that has been designed especially to provide a comfortable, unchanged sleeping experience – but since this is an encasement that will seal the mattress off, you should be prepared for some heating

Its MiteTight seams, in conjunction with a lockable zipper, completely close off your mattress against insect threats and pet dander that would otherwise seriously compromise its lifetime. Furthermore, if you’ve already got an infestation, it will keep the creepy crawlies in until they run out of air and die.

An anti-microbial silver chloride lining counters the growth of mold and fungi from any residual moisture. It is also noteworthy that this cover, just like all other PureCare products, comes with an OEKO-Tex® certification, which means it is free from hazardous substances.

I haven’t come across any complaints with regards to failed waterproofing, and the product has also been praised for its noiselessness as you sleep on it.

Pros

    • Total protection against bedbugs, dust mites, pet dander, and fluids.
    • OmniGuard Advance fabric makes for low profile.
    • Silver chloride actively combats microbial growth.
    • Can be laundered in hot water for thorough cleaning.

Cons

    • Six sided form factor may lead to heating.
    • Expensive.

Recommended For

The Total Encasement Mattress Protector from PureCare is meant for consumers who want complete protection against mites, fluids, and bedbugs.

Slumber Cloud Dryline Mattress Protector

Key Points

    • Material: Polyester 98% / Lycra surface, Outlast(R) PCM, plastic membrane
    • Waterproof: Yes
    • Allergen Proof: Yes
    • Bed Bug Proof: No
    • Extra Features: Outlast(R) Gold standard phase change mechanism, made in USA
    • Warranty: 60 days

By utilizing Outlast(R) phase change thermocules in its core, this US-made cover is able to absorb excess heat given off by your body as you sleep. Once the temperature of your skin begins to cool down, heat is released from the thermocules to ensure that you don’t get too cold.

This temperature regulation yields a restful sleep surface regardless of the time of the year - and even works with thermally incompatible couples. The surface itself is made out of a lycra/polyester blend, which yields comfort with some durability.

The waterproofing is standard fare - a plastic membrane to block out fluids and allergens. Consumer feedback about the product has been vastly positive thanks to the way it safeguards your mattress without the usual sweat-inducing plastic sensation.

A 30 day money back guarantee as well as a 60 day manufacturer’s warranty accompany the Dryline protector.

Pros

    • Comfortable top surface.
    • Active temperature management solution with Outlast(R) technology.
    • Can provide individualized cooling/heating for thermally incompatible couples.
    • Reliable protection.
    • 30 day money back guarantee.

Cons

    • Somewhat expensive.
    • 60 day warranty is somewhat stingy.

Recommended For

This cover is targeted at temperature sensitive sleepers who want an active heat management solution to ensure an individually restful sleeping experience.

Conclusion

Having reached the end of this guide, you will now have realized that the choice of the best mattress cover is largely dependent upon the intended application as well as how much you’re willing to compromise on the temperature rise / change in feel.

The fact remains that the most reliable protector will always cause some heating and alter the surface feel of your bed – you’ll need to select the product that serves you just right and nothing more. For instance, those who are only concerned about random, infrequent spills may go with a cool, comfy organic top product, but those who are dealing with continuous bedwetting will need a tough plastic protector that can be readily laundered.

With that said, I would go with the Protect-A-Bed Luxury Waterproof Mattress Protector because it combines reliable and adequate protection for the average consumer while also offering super comfort thanks to its Tencel based surface.

If you’re in need of something less expensive and more durable, you could look at the Priva Vinyl Protector – but be warned: this will not be especially comfortable.

Leave a Comment:

All fields with “*” are required

Leave a Comment:

All fields with “*” are required