The Best Mattress Protectors On The Market - Buyers Guide

Keeping your mattress protected is the best thing that you can do to ensure the longevity of your bed. Not only that, but it also helps to keep your warranty intact. If anything were to spill on it, your warranty would be void. I can personally attest to the fact that mattress companies do not take back beds that have been soaked in sweat or have stains on them. So, with this said, I want to make sure that you are able to easily find the best mattress protector for your bed to keep your mattress fresh, clean, and covered.

Looking for something for bed bugs? We recommend a mattress encasement.​

Best Mattress Protector Comparisons

Brand

Special Feature

Weight

Warranty

Prices

Our Ratings

LUNA

Hypoallergenic

1 pound

10 Year Manufacturer's Warranty

$$$$$

Read Our Review

SKY Bedding

Hypoallergenic

2.1 pounds

Lifetime Manufacturer’s Warranty​

$$

Read Our Review

Sleep Tite

Hypoallergenic

2 pounds

15 Year Manufacturer's Warranty

$$$$

Read Our Review

SafeRest

Hypoallergenic

1 pound

10 Year Manufacturer's Warranty

$$$

Read Our Review

LinenSpa

Hypoallergenic

1.6 pounds

10 Year Manufacturer's Warranty​

$

Read Our Review

What Are They For?

As I said earlier, mattress protectors help to ensure that your bed stays protected to make it last longer and keep it covered under warranty, but, they are not only good for that. They are ideal for allergy protection, bedwetting protection, comfort and more.

Allergies

Dust mites are one of the leading dust allergy triggers while you are sleeping or in bed. If you suffer from sneezing, runny or stuffy nose, red, itchy or watery eyes, wheezing, chest tightness, shortness of breath, wheezing, or itching, you probably have a dust allergy that is set off by the mites or pet dander. Not only can you suffer from those various symptoms, but a dust mite allergy is a very common cause for asthma in children. One simple way you can prevent these allergies is to protect your bed with a hypoallergenic protector.

Bedwetting

Also known as “nighttime incontinence”, bedwetting is a common occurrence in children and elderly adults with bladder control issues. The most common protector for this issue are made from vinyl and can sometimes be referred to as “plastic sheets”. They can be easily wiped clean and can last quite a few years if taken care of properly. If one of these are on your bed, you are helping to keep moisture away from the mattress, which can cause a void in your warranty and a not so nice smell in your room.

Comfort

Yup, it is as simple as that, a protector for comfort. Some people do like to keep their mattresses protected from sweat, dust, dander, spills, and bed bugs, but they also like to add just a touch of softness as well. You can find mattress protectors that have comfort fill that acts like a pillow top for your bed. So, instead of spending the extra money on a fancy pillow top mattress, you can save a few hundred or even thousands of dollars by investing in a fluffy cotton protector.

Types Of Mattress Protectors

Unlike other products, you can get mattress protectors in a variety of different textures, materials, depths and more because not everyone has the same preference. I would like show you how many different options you have when it comes to purchasing the best mattress cover for you.

Membrane Versus Non-Membrane

These options are ideal for those who suffer from allergies. Membrane covers help to protect your bed by offering a waterproof top with a non-fabric barrier. You can also get this option with a zipper that helps to protect your mattress from bed bugs.

Non-Membrane covers feel similar to cotton and have a tightly woven fabric that does not allow the allergens to pass through the barrier. They are silent, lightweight, and comfortable, but they do not have the waterproof effect like the membrane covers do.​

Fitted Versus Zippered

When choosing between fitted and zippered, you should keep your strength and bug protection preference in mind. If you want to protect yourself against bed bugs and other critters that could enter your mattress, you are going to want a zippered protector. This will ensure that the entire bed is protected because it wraps the entire thing from top to bottom.

​Fitted protectors are quick and simple to install and they do not involve you picking up the mattress. They are just like a fitted sheet and usually have elastic edges to keep it in place. These types, however, only protect against moisture, sweat, mildew, etc. They will not keep the bed safe from bugs.

Organic Versus Non-Organic

You read it right, there are such things are organic mattress protectors. Organic protectors are made from all-natural fibers that were grown without the use of harmful chemicals, pesticides or synthetic fertilizers. They also help to provide a healthier sleeping environment by protecting against allergens with their hypoallergenic properties. These are great for those who have allergies, eczema, delicate skin or asthma.

If you are an an environmental advocate, it is another reason to go with organic because they are better for the environment. Instead of using potentially harmful and dangerous pesticides, farmers use sustainable farming methods when growing their cotton, helping to make these protectors biodegradable. On the downside, these are more expensive since they are organic.

Also, make sure you are actually getting a 100% natural cover if you are choosing organic. Sometimes, companies will tell you that their product is organic when they really aren’t. All you need to look for is the GOTS label. This stands for Global Organic Textile Standard and is only used if something is 100% natural.

Non-organic mattress protectors are usually made with flame retardants and other unhealthy chemicals and materials such as vinyl and urethane, which are most commonly used in the waterproof covers. Non-organic products are filled with toxins and may not be as healthy for you or your children. The only upside to these are that they are less expensive and have more options.​

Vinyl Versus Urethane

This applies to a mattress protector that is deemed “waterproof”. I can’t tell you how many times I have heard someone complain that their protector was not 100% waterproof. Well, the problem with this is that not all of these covers are made with the same materials and are sometimes only “water resistant” rather than waterproof. Also, not all waterproof protectors are made the same and each have their own different features.

A vinyl barrier tends to not be breathable, but they are more economical. They are also very noisy and take more time to dry. If you are someone who does not like to be warm while you sleep, vinyl would not be an ideal choice for you because they tend to be hot to sleep on.

A vinyl barrier tends to not be breathable, but they are more economical. They are also very noisy and take more time to dry. If you are someone who does not like to be warm while you sleep, vinyl would not be an ideal choice for you because they tend to be hot to sleep on.

Urethane barriers, on the other hand, allow heat transfer and they will stay cool during the summer and warm in the winter. They are generally more quiet than vinyl and they wash and dry at a faster rate of time. The downside is that they cost more, but, they do last longer, so the additional cost is probably well worth it.​

How Do They Differ?

Contrary to what some may believe, mattress protectors differ from mattress pads and encasements for many reasons. A lot of people will buy a pad thinking that it will protect their bed, but they don’t always do that, this is why it is important to know the difference.

Protectors

Protectors are usually like a fitted sheet. They fit on your bed, based on size, and help to protect your mattress against allergens, moisture, bacteria and more. These are generally much cheaper than encasements and pads, but they offer more protection against liquids. Although, this is not always the case if the protector is not completely waterproof.

Encasements

Encasements are more for bed bug protection. Yes, they do offer complete coverage for your mattress, but they are not always waterproof. They will keep the bed bugs away, but they will not keep liquid out which could void your warranty.

Toppers

A mattress topper is more for comfort than protection.They are usually in memory foam or eggshell form and are a few inches thick. A lot of people will go out and buy a pad but find that they get ruined just as quickly as a mattress without a protector on it. These are also way more expensive with little to no protection.

Mattress Protector Reviews

Luna Premium Hypoallergenic 100% Waterproof Mattress Protector-Queen

Key Points

  • 12 x 3.5 x 12 inches
  • 1 pound
  • ​Waterproof
  • ​Hypoallergenic
  • Fits up to 18”
  • 10-year warranty

To ensure that everyone has the option to choose the Luna Mattress Protector, they have 7 sizes to choose from that fit any standard size bed. They also took the added precaution and designed a Sure-Fit sizing band that fits up to 18 inch mattresses. They also went ahead and added a waterproof membrane that protects your bed from spills and moisture. If it gets wet, just take it off and throw it in the washer per manufacturer instructions.

​This protector is also ideal for those who may be suffering from allergies. It helps to prevent allergy triggers from getting through the membrane material while also allowing the mattress to breathe. We can thank the exclusive Airflow technology for this feature.

The microscopic pores allow air to pass through while blocking anything else that shouldn’t. The hypoallergenic cotton terry surface will not disrupt sleep from being noisy like vinyl does. It will also not change the feel of your mattress. If for any reason you need to return the Luna, you are covered by a 10-year warranty.

Pros

  • Noiseless
  • True fit
  • Good quality construction
  • Breathable
  • Truly waterproof
  • 10-year warranty
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Lightweight
  • No smell

Cons

  • Some people still slept hot
  • Complaints of leaks
  • Stretched out

Recommended For

Ideal for those who may be suffering from allergies.


Sky Bedding 100% Waterproof Mattress Protector-Queen

Key Points

  • 60 x 80 inches
  • 2.1 pounds
  • Waterproof
  • ​Hypoallergenic
  • Fits up to 22”
  • Lifetime Manufacturer’s Warranty

Sky Bedding has created a mattress protector that is ideal for keeping your mattress dry and clean, guaranteed. This hypoallergenic cover helps to protect your bed from stains, moisture, spills, and more. It is extremely easy to put on and it can be washed in the washing machine, no matter what size.

This protector can fit a mattress up to a whopping 22” and will stay in place without hassle. As it is on your bed, it will help to protect you against pesky allergens and germs. You may no longer wake up to red, itchy eyes, a stuffy or runny nose, and you won’t have to spend half of your night sneezing and sniffling due to dust mites or other triggers.

You will also not have to worry about crinkly sounds or noisy movement during the night since this protector is not made from vinyl, PVC or phthalates, which is what normally makes the crinkle sound on the waterproof barrier. The tind cover will leave your mattress just as comfortable as it has always been. You will also not sleep hot with the breathable cotton terry surface.​

Pros

  • Easy to install
  • Deep pockets-can fit a topper
  • Noiseless
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Affordable
  • Doesn’t change feel of mattress
  • Easy to wash
  • Doesn’t cause hot sleeping
  • Fits perfectly

Cons

  • Complaints of it not being breathable
  • A few complaints of leaks
  • Stretched out

Sleep Tite by Malouf® Hypoallergenic 100% Waterproof Mattress Protector-Queen

Key Points

  • 60 x 80 inches
  • 2 pounds
  • ​Waterproof
  • ​Hypoallergenic
  • Fits up to 22”
  • 15-year warranty

Fitting at an amazing 16 sizes, the Sleep Tite has an option for literally everyone, which includes RV size beds and cribs/cots. You will also find that these fitted sheet style protectors fit mattresses up to 22” deep and protects against all fluids thanks to its 100% waterproof barrier. Since the average person can lose up to 1 liter of liquid a night, the Sleep Tite has the capability to absorb up to that 1 liter with its polyurethane membrane.

The way this protector works is by preventing the accumulation of moisture and skin sheddings that escapes our bodies each night. These flakes mixed with moisture is the perfect feeding and breeding ground for bacteria and dust mites. Dust mites have been a proven factor in children’s asthma, a trigger for those who have asthma, and one of the leading causes of eczema. This protector cuts off all food supplies to these mites and kills them off, thus, reducing allergies.

A great bonus feature of this protector is that it helps body heat to pass through the mattress resulting in a cooler night of sleep. The fabric will not change the feel of your mattress as it conforms to the shape of it naturally.​

Pros

  • PVC, Vinyl, and Phthalate free
  • Naturally absorbs moisture
  • Comfortable
  • Easy to put on
  • Easy to wash
  • No overheating
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Deep pockets
  • Users noticed reduced allergy symptoms

Cons

  • Not completely noiseless
  • Has an odor
  • Complaints of leaks

Recommended For

Fitting at an amazing 16 sizes, the Sleep Tite has an option for literally everyone, which includes RV size beds and cribs/cots.

SafeRest Premium Hypoallergenic Waterproof Mattress Protector-Vinyl Free-Queen

Key Points

  • 1 pound
  • 60 x 80 inches
  • ​Waterproof
  • ​Hypoallergenic
  • ​Fits up to 18”
  • 10-year warranty

The SafeRest is registered with the FDA as a class 1 medical device along with being hypoallergenic. It protects against dust mites, allergens, bacteria, perspiration, urine and fluids. It is helpful for those who may have pets, allergies, children or incontinence. This protector traps fluids, dust mites,skin cells and other irritants on the surface where they can be washed away during the advised quarterly launderings. This will ensure an allergen free environment for sleeping for the entire family.

The cotton terry surface is breathable, noiseless, and will keep you cool as you sleep. You may be thinking “how can it be waterproof without a vinyl top”? Well, cotton terry naturally absorbs moisture while being noiseless and since the back of it is coated with a waterproof and hypoallergenic membrane layer, it keeps the moisture at bay.

​Thanks to the SafeRest Invisa-ShieldTM technology, this protector will not change the feel of your mattress. This is ideal for all types of mattresses including innerspring, memory foam and latex. What makes it even more of an ideal choice is that it is backed by a full replacement 10-year product warranty.

Pros

  • Registered with the FDA
  • Breathable
  • Tests proved waterproof
  • Washable
  • Easy to install
  • Comfortable
  • Affordable
  • Doesn’t crinkle
  • Doesn’t sleep hot

Cons

  • Doesn’t wrap around the whole bed
  • Strong smell
  • Not completely noiseless

Recommended For

This is ideal for all types of mattresses including innerspring, memory foam and latex.

LINENSPA Premium Mattress Protector-Queen

Key Points

  • 60 x 80 inches
  • 1.6 pounds
  • ​Hypoallergenic
  • ​Waterproof
  • 10-year warranty
  • Fits up to 18”

The fully elasticized fitted sheet style LINENSPA Premium Mattress Protector makes protecting your mattress a breeze. The deep pockets help to ensure a smooth and secure fit on mattresses up to 18” deep without changing the natural feel of it. This is a great feature because you can’t have a fully protected mattress if the sides keep popping up, exposing it to allergens and bugs.

The hypoallergenic fabric of this cover is made with a noiseless polyurethane backing helps to block allergens, dust mites, and other allergy triggers while being waterproof. The 100% waterproof top surface helps to keep liquids, perspiration, urine, bodily fluids and accidental spills away from your mattress, which also keeps your warranty intact.

You will also be able to sleep better knowing that the breathable barrier does not make you sleep hot. The air will pass through the barrier for comfort while keeping everything else out. If you have any issues with it, you are covered by a 10-year warranty.​

Pros

  • Deep pocket design
  • Has a breathable barrier
  • Comfortable
  • Easy to maintain
  • Good Quality
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Affordable

Cons

  • Makes noise
  • Claims of failed waterproof backing

The Best One Is..

After reviewing everything about all of these products, there is no doubt in my mind that the Sleep Tite by Malouf® Hypoallergenic 100% Waterproof Mattress Protector is the ideal choice here. Yes,the other ones are great too, but this one is the only one that can fit 16 different size mattresses, including cribs and cots.

There were very minimal reviews stating that it wasn’t truly waterproof and it is free from 3 main harmful chemicals. If I were to put a mattress protector on my bed, this one would be it. It may be the most expensive one on the list, but usually the rule of thumb is that you get what you pay for, and if I am paying more for this one, I would hope that it gives more than the others.​

Leave a Comment:

All fields with “*” are required

Leave a Comment:

All fields with “*” are required